Blog Stats

Site Meter
Blog Hits Since 29/11/2007 and Counting

Scrolls 40 Most Recent Comments

“Terry Jones initially said that the Koran burning had been cancelled. Th...
Could you make a post on your site of who are the true prophets. Thanks....
What is your purpose for pulling down these men and women of God.Who appoin...
such a great article!!! wow!!! so so good so clear!! thank you Johan!! ...
Fanie van Staden wrote: Guys, you are being very hard on Hans. Not incorre...
To Donna - From - Admin moved your comment to correct thread. Donn...
Mostly women supporting ray again. would they like to try for spot number t...
“Dr. Leonard Sweet is making his way into otherwise conservative evangeli...
Donna I found this on the net about Joseph Prince just google his name a...
Donna If you are talking about Joseph Prince. He is all over TBN televis...
Genesis 34.1-29. 1. Samuel 18:14-29. 2 Samuel 12:11. 2. Samuel 13:11. ...
Hi Louise. I get a hunger for the Lord by reading His book, not the works o...
Hi Paul, God can use anything or anybody to speak to you. You having a h...
'the latest thing is to use metaphors, poetry, and riddles when preaching' ...
Deborah, yes, I have read and continue to read and study the Bible. My inte...
Paul wrote: Elmarie. Benny Hinndu is a 33 degree Freemason, lol lol lol...
“Church Going Global Published September 7th, 2010 by Editor in General,...
This is just more proof that Rhema is evil, it would have to be evil to all...
Elmarie. Benny Hinndu is a 33 degree Freemason, that should tell you someth...
Louise. China is actually a tool of the NWO. In 1920 Rothschild went to Ch...
“A small US church says it will defy international condemnation and go ah...
Mzansi wrote: Whst do you think about this prophecy by one Jonathan Hansen...
I don't think it is being hard on someone to address damanging error - one ...
Pastor Renny Masetsola wrote: we can not judge someone’s servant in our ...
we can not judge someone's servant in our worldly form. Ray is the man of G...
Whst do you think about this prophecy by one Jonathan Hansen. http://www...
Ian Armstrong Subject: Troubled by Calvinists Question: Dr. Craig, ...
Burning Lamp A hearty welcome back from us all !! We must cling to ...
CHRISTIAN BROADCASTING NETWORK PEDDLING CONTEMPLATIVE SPIRITUALITY T...
Ian, you think you have found the truth, but you have bought into yet anoth...
Paul, a hearty amen to your comments. We can expect to be maligned and shut...
I inquired about this man who was being touted by a so-called discernment s...
Roy wrote: As far as Benny goes, I know there are may opinions out there, ...
Paula Rhee wrote: Have u heard of Dr. David Owour from Kenya? He prophesie...
More teens becoming ‘fake’ Christians Published September 6th, 201...
Paul wrote: Hi Elmarie. The next step will be to refer to God as the Andro...
Hi Elijah. Visualization is Withcraft. Read Leviticus and Deuteronomy. I...
Hi Elmarie. The next step will be to refer to God as the Androgynous god (o...
RACHEL wrote I think same people judge her and train to put her and her hu...
Ferdinand - You mean the guy who put bombs in stations to blow up men, wome...

Map o’ Visitors

Locations of visitors to this page
ClustrMaps Visitor Count Started: 02/08/2009

Blog Bling

False Foundation of Five-Fold Ministry

false-foundation-of-five-fold-ministry

Five Fold Ministry - © Discerningtheworld.com - Fair use Copyright, Please credit and link to www.discerningtheworld.com if you use this image.FALSE FOUNDATION BUILT BY MEN

Christian Research Institute Journal

The Faulty Foundation of the Five-Fold Ministry

by Robert M. Bowman, Jr.

from the Viewpoint column of the Christian Research Journal, Fall 1987, page 31. The Editor-in-Chief of the Christian Research Journal is Elliot Miller.

It has recently become popular to speak of “the five-fold ministry,” a system of church government with apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors, and teachers. The neo-Pentecostal “Restoration” movement and its offshoot, “kingdom now” teaching, claims that one of the things which God is “restoring” to the church is this five-fold ministry. The sole prooftext used to support this concept is Ephesians 4:11-13, which states that Christ gave “some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers,…until we all attain to the unity of the faith and the full knowledge of the Son of God.” The word “until,” it is argued, proves that the church today needs apostles and prophets as much as evangelists, pastors, and teachers. However, it is the “building up” of the church (v.12) which must continue until the church is mature, not all five of the offices listed in verse 11. This is clear when the whole text is read as follows: “And He gave some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers; [these offices were given] to equip the saints for the work of service, [which work has as its goal] to build up the body of Christ until we all attain to the unity of the faith…” The offices of apostle and prophet would naturally cease in the church once their role in “equipping the saints” was completed; that is, once the New Testament canon was completed.

Some have objected that there is no reason to bracket off the apostles and prophets from the other three offices listed in verse 11. However, in the very same epistle, Paul states that the church has “been built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets” (Eph. 2:20) and that Christ’s mystery concerning the church was “revealed to His holy apostles and prophets in the Spirit” (3:5). These statements indicate that the role of apostles and prophets was fulfilled in the first century.

The New Testament is particularly clear about the temporary role of the apostles, since they were chosen to give eyewitness testimony of the risen Christ (Acts 1:21-26; 5:32; Luke 1:1-4; 1 Cor. 9:1). Paul indicated that he was the last person to see the risen Christ and receive an apostolic commission (1 Cor. 15:8). The epistles of 2 Peter and Jude, among the very last New Testament writings to be penned, exhort the readers to avoid false doctrines by recalling the teachings of the apostles (2 Pet. 1:12-15; 2:1; 3:2, 14-16; Jude 3-4, 17). Peter and Jude did not say, “Listen to the apostles living today,” but instead urged believers to “remember what the apostles said.”

I am not arguing that only the Twelve and Paul were apostles. Barnabas (Acts 14:14), Silas (1 Thess. 2:6; cf. 1:1), and Andronicus and Junia (Rom. 16:7) all were apostles of Christ, and thus were no doubt among the more than 500 witnesses to the Resurrection (1 Cor. 15:6). However, none of these persons was chosen as a successor to an earlier apostle (Matthias was Judas’s replacement, not his successor, since Judas had forsaken his apostleship, Acts 1:21-26).

There are other senses in which the word “apostle” is used in the New Testament. Certain individuals, including Epaphroditus, were “apostles of the churches” (2 Cor. 8:23; Phil. 2:25). These “apostles” had no authority over the church; they were messengers sent by and subject to their churches. In this latter sense it would be perfectly legitimate to speak of church representatives as “apostles,” were it not for the confusion which might result from such usage.

Therefore, in the usual biblical sense of the term, there are no apostles today. Nor are there any prophets in the usual sense, as they were part of the “foundation” laid in the first-century church. This is not to deny the continuing validity of the gift of “prophecy,” since Paul does refer to prophesying as a basic activity in which all Christians are urged to participate to the extent God gifts them (Rom. 12:6; 1 Cor. 11:4-5; 12:10; 13:2, 8-9; 14:1-6, 20-33; 1 Thess. 5:20), and in a general functional sense persons exercising this gift are even called “prophets” (1 Cor. 14:32,37). Yet Paul also speaks of specific persons who occupied an office of “prophet” which was second in authority only to apostle (1 Cor. 12:28-29). It is this office of “prophet,” not all prophecy, which I am arguing passed away around the end of the first century.

Finally, some errors on this matter are worse than others. The loose use of the world “apostle” to refer to missionaries or church planters is not a serious error as long as this usage is sharply distinguished from the concept of an apostle who brings new doctrinal revelations and wields unquestionable authority. Nor is it a grievous error to interpret Ephesians 4:11 to refer to “apostles” in this sense of a church planter. The same would apply to those who hold that Ephesians 4:11 refers to the ongoing charismatic activity of prophesying. I do believe these interpretations are mistaken, but they are not in any way antagonistic to Christian faith.

On the other hand, to interpret Ephesians 4:11 as a call for a restoration of the office of apostle of Christ is not only a mistake in exegesis, it opens the door to heresy. To claim that the church today needs visions and revelations through modern apostles and prophets of Christ is to deny the sufficiency of the Bible (2 Tim. 3:16) and to place the church at the mercy of false apostles, the likes of whom the apostle Paul warned us about in no uncertain terms (2 Cor. 11:13-15).

The teachers of the “five-fold ministry,” in seeking to “restore” a foundation which has never been moved, are actually laying a false foundation which will not support the building up of the body of Christ.

—–

End of document, CRJ0009A.TXT (original CRI file name),
“The Faulty Foundation of the Five-Fold Ministry”
release A, September 6, 1993
R. Poll, CRI

© Copyright 1993 by the Christian Research Institute.

Source:   http://www.iclnet.org/pub/resources/text/cri/cri-jrnl/web/crj0009a.html

—–

1 comment to False Foundation of Five-Fold Ministry

  • Lydia Emery

    Dear One:
    As an ‘unexpert’ in biblical exegesis may I suggest that the existence of the false apostle/prophet movement in no way changes the Word of God. Rather it validates it.
    The Ephesians 4:11 states how God designed the church.
    The counterfeit copying of the true does not negate the true.
    We need the true Holy Ghost to discern the difference.
    Praise the Lord Jesus Christ at all times and may He give us all much discernment in these last and terribly deceptive days.
    Needing more of HIM,
    Lydia Emery

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

Announcements:

List of All Articles

Why would a Christian use a Menorah?

Signs and Wonders

Nelson Mandela as Jesus Christ

Chipped, Fingerprinted and Eyeballed

Anti Christian Globalism Approaches the Final Stage

Educate your Child into the Anti-Christ’s hands

What is ‘KJV Only’?

Actress Julia Roberts embraces Hinduism

Benny Hinn and the Neanderthal Man

Jesus appears in Nigeria – AUGUST 2010

Dr William Craig – Historical New Reformation Debate (transcript)

Redistribution of Wealth on the Way

G8 World Religions Summit – Worships Mother Earth

Kim Clement Admits he is a False Prophet

The Rise of World Wide Slavery

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: August 2010

The Legacy of John Calvin – Part 1

Just Sign it!

Ivin Viljoen – The Fires of Hell Burn Bright for 220Genergation

Johan van Wyk – Solid Rock Church With Not So Solid Advertising

Speaking in Tongues

Back to Rome in 40 Days

Europe’s anti-Semetism Rises

ANC likens Madiba to Moses

Xenophobia in South Africa

Final Preparations to Receive the New Age Christ

Moreleta Park, Bruce Wilkinson and the Amazonic “Jesus”

Spiritual Deception, Revival and Angus Buchan

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: July 2010

Have You or a Loved One Been Raised From the Dead?

Discerning the World Announcement.

Todd Bentley – Restored and Changed

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: June 2010

John Piper – Accepting One Mountain with All the Others

Was lost, but now I’m found – by Google

Faith & Reason Conference – Sat 15 May 2010

Ingrid Schlueter – Celebrates Holy Cross Day

John MacArthur – The Blood of Jesus is just Liquid!

Emergent: Why Can’t Everybody be Right?

Faith & Reason Conference – Christians vs Non-Christians

Cindy Jacobs – Right Wing Xtian Nazi Communist

Faith & Reason Conference (10-15 May 2010 – South Africa)

Andrew Strom gets it WRONG again…

Eternal Security – Genuinely Saved, Always Saved!

The Church Is Not Israel – God Deals With Each One Separately

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: May 2010

The Annointed Scamsters

Another Gospel

Twelve Reasons for the Rapture

Cape Town for ‘Dion, Graham and Angus’ 2010

The Rapture – An Article to Blow Your Hair Back!

Demonic Attacks on Believers’ Faith throughout the Ages

What did YOU think Revival meant?

Boere-Afrikaners, Jode en Israel

Paul Washer – Practice the Presence: Silence and Meditation

Stand Up and be Counted – Might Men Conference 2010

Smart Cards on their way SA

You can drive, but you won’t get very far!

From Darkness to the Light – Salvation through Jesus Christ

Christian Right Fuses with Apostolic Dominionism

There is No God like Jehovah …

Israelvisie volhard met hulle dwalings

Calvinism a Heretical Doctrine – That’s What the Bible Says!

Calvinism II: Total Hereditary Depravity

Calvinism I: An Introduction to Calvinism

UN Millennium Declaration Development Goals – 2015 Deadline

Die Verbondsvolk Israel: Wie is Hulle?

Siener van Rensburg en die Boerevolk

Rick Joyner – Dressed as a Knight of Malta

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: April 2010

Hell – What Does the Bible Says About It

British Israelism and the ‘Lost Tribes’ Identity Chrisis

John Piper – Taking Leave and Asks for Forgiveness

Ten Kinds of Foolishness and then Some

What do you do when?

Green Police

Some of the TOP CONTENDERS for THE AntiChrist Position are:

The New Evangelical – Evil fit for a New Dark Age

Rebecca Brown – WARNING! Don’t Bind Yourself in her Books

Chris Oyakhilome – Jesus is NOT Gods Word anymore, You are!!

Vatican II and The New Evangelization World Wide Take Over

Nancy Missler and Henrietta Mears

Ungodly Christian Pastors in our Churches?

Minister Tries to Take Down Discerning the World

Dion Forster and The Drive By Rebuking Video

John MacArthur I pray this is NOT true!

AGE OF AQUARIUS – A NEW AGE, A NEW DAWN

Turn2God at the Union Buildings was…

Lee Grady – Take the Holy Ghost out that box He is stuck in

Andrew Strom sends his sheep into the ‘Unusual’

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: Mar 2010

Benny Hinn – Miracle Service in Durban – 13 Mar 2010

Mystery ‘Christ blowing his Trumpet’ at Mossel Bay has been Identified

The NEW but Quite OLD Apostamation and Refopostasy

Kathryn Kuhlman – The Interfaith Faith Healer

Zuma and Ray McCauley want a Moral Code for South Africa

South Africans Reclaiming That Dominion Mandate To Dominate

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: Feb 2010

Christ appears in cloud at Mosselbay

Dr. Chuck Missler, SWANsat and the Auric™ Currency

Do Not Let Him Into Your Home

Ray McCauley: Divorce No.2

Springboks ‘Healed’ by TB Joshua Sadly Pass Away

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: Jan 2010

Louie Giglio – Chasing The Experience (Part 1)

Louie Giglio – Sometimes Silence is Loud

Louie Giglio – A Baptist with an Emerging Agenda

Andrew Strom – Trying to Transform Africa with False Christianity

Bobs Your-Anchor is Looking for Assistant News Reporters

The Rapture – An Article to Knock Your Socks Off

Wars and Rumours of Wars

Patricia King – 2010: Be Fruitful, Bear Many Children

Rick Warren – Gets $2.4m in Donations

TD Jakes – 20 is 10 Carried Into a Double Dimension

Heresy-Hunters, Apologists and Humourless Satirists

The Whole Counsel of God

Abide With Us

News Desk by Bobs Your-Anchor: Dec 2009

Is Contemplative Prayer (Meditation) Biblical?

IHOP – Contemplative Prayer Taught at Healing Rooms

Mike Bickle – Everybody is Called to Live in The Contemplative Lifestyle

Kansas City Awakens to Revival at IHOP – RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!

Christian Bank is Coming to SA

Mark Driscoll DOES SUPPORT Contemplative Spirituality

Cobus van Wyngaard – Avatar Portrays Wonderful World of Perfect Pantheism

Why did Copenhagen fail?

Prt 1 – A Biblical Appraisal of the Mosaic Congress – Mosaic Church, Johannesburg (4–5 Sep 09)

1 in 3 Democrats Communicate with the Dead

Pantheism – Hollywood’s Religion of Choice for a Generation Now

Allah is a Translation for God

Which Steps Have You Taken to Aid World Transformation?

Changing Your DNA for Spiritual Transcendance?

Reinhard Bonnke and Daniel Kolenda – 3yr old Boy Raised from the Dead

Mark Driscoll’s RESURGENCE and EMERGENCE with Catholicism

False Foundation of Five-Fold Ministry

Rhema Church – Believe Belong Become God

Pastor in Court for R2m Fraud

Rick Warren – A Recipe For Disaster

FIFA says Free Education for Africa – What does the fine print say?

Can Jesus Christ The Son of God Trust You?

Are Catholics Christian?

Isa al Masih – The Muslim’s Jesus Christ

Manhattan Declaration – WARNING – Leads You Toward A New Religion

Ekstasis Worship – Moving Beyond Oneself Even As Far As Uganda

Uganda’s New Apostolic Reformation Transformation Disaster

Your Sons and Your Daughters Will Prophesy, But Not Yet…

To Tattoo or Not too Tattoo, That is the Biblical Question

Kobus van Rensburg is Building a Little Empire

Caught Up By Jesus Christ Or Caught By A False Christ

Brian McLaren Thinks Again! On Stuff…

Pope Mortified that he was found practicing Mortification

National Initiative for the Reformation of South Africa – NIRSA

A Tale of Two Trees

Graham Power & Angus Buchan – The Transformation of Africa

Global Earth Management Crazy Talk

In Plain Words

Playing the Pharisee Card

Jesus Christ to Step Down

No Liberation from Resurrecting Liberation Theology

The New Way

The Third Way vs The Only Way

Scripture – Be of Sober Spirit, Take up the Full Armour of God

You’ve got 4 types of Christians…

One World Language in More Ways than One

We Do Not Play ‘Sloshed in the Spirit’ Anymore

EU to name first permanent president on 19 Nov 2009

Angus Buchan and the Promise Keepers

A Listener’s Guide to the Pulpit

Kim Clement – Obama is God’s Man

Coca-Cola Happiness Song BUT ONLY IF…

What a Tragedy ‘Prophet’ Kobus van Rensburg

Prophet Vincent Xavier and the Fallout Refugees

12 Murdered because of ‘Hate Speech’?

Democracy is Over

False Teachers and Prophets – Methods of Operation

Cindy Jacobs – Two Truly False Prophecies for Zimbabwe and Africa

Help Bail Ray McCauley out of Debt!

Joyce Meyer Ministries Security Manager Commits Murder

Rick Joyner and Jesus speak on Health Care

John Shelby Spong – Victory over Biblical Christianity

Choo Thomas – Heaven is so Real – Is it Really?

Patricia King and the Blue Flame of the Cosmic Christ

Marjoe Gortner – Oldest Tricks in the Book

Morris Cerullo – Financial Breakthrough Bible To Build Joels Army

We Can Do An Equitable Global Governance Structure

Brian McLaren Letter to Obama: Give Al Queda $65 billion – Yes We Can

Is Obama Poised to Cede US Sovereignty to NWO in Dec 2009?

A Fascinating Interview with Obama

‘Everything Must Change’ Back to Roman Catholicism

Ray McCauley & Joel ‘Stop talking to God’ Osteen – Coca Cola Dome (23-24 Oct 2009)

Benny Hinn – Obama is a Good Man, a Christian Man

Benny Hinn – God Never Called Me to Verify. I’m Not a Doctor

Al-Qaeda Jihadists Plot Attack Against FIFA 2010 World Cup

The Father of a One World Currency

The Proper Distinction of Law and Gospel

The Religious Left Discovers Radical Islam

EU Plans for World Power

Integral Spiritual Experience come New Years Eve 2009

Barack Hussein Obama Deserves Nobel Peace Prize

SURPRISE! Obama Wins Nobel Peace Prize!

Dream Interpretation #3 – Soccer

Benny Hinn Denied

How far is too far?

The Gnostic Roots of the Latter Rain/Word of Faith Movement

Worlds Most Metaphorically Dangerous Job

7 Colours of the Rainbow and the 7 Chakras

The AntiChrist is NOT just about Islam

Guillaume Smit and the “Culture” of Islam?

Peter Veysie from Ridgeway Ministries trying to ‘Bridge’ that Gap

Christians hauled before court after defending their beliefs

Gay man sues Zondervan for mental anguish

7 Colours of the Rainbow and the Labyrinth

1 Rainbow, 6 Billion Smurfs and a New World Order

Is Ron Martoia, Stephan Joubert and Nelus Niemandt Experts in their Field?

One World Global Currency Lurks Around the Corner

Revisiting: The Christian Bully vs The False Teacher

Swine Flu – The Virus Against Terror

Church of England and the Nazi Christmas Carol

Church Leaders Judging Israel – How convenient for them!

The Christian Bully vs The False Teacher

Ee-mmergency! Releasing Christian Youth Into The Fire!

A New World Order Airport with an Arrangement of Occult Art

Brian McLaren is going to celebrate Ramadan on 21 Aug 2009

Thabo Mbeki, Jacob Zuma and Angus Buchan walk into a New Age Bar

New Prayers for The New Age

Elect are Lost but Reprobates are Not

The Gospel According to Islam or the Emerging One World Faith?

Peter Rollins: ‘The Last Supper’ Rings a Bell

Rob Bell, Shane Hipps, Peter Rollins teaching Arts and Crafts? No, Never, Cant be!

Prepared For The Slaughter – The Disarming Of The Church

Sadhu Sundar Singh – Hindu Mystic in Sheep’s Clothing

Discernamentalist Mafia

Love Casts Out All Hell

South African Compulsory Regulation to Intercept Communications – RICA (1 July 2009)

Satan the Trickster – Embracing the Emerging Snake

Elza Meyer Attacked by Demons, Saved by Son

The Fire

Born Again Christians are Now Compared to Inquisitors of the Inquisitions

God Does Not Exist, Man Does

He Comes Bearing Gifts…

The Positive and The Negative of a One World Religion

Christianity Defaced as Emergent Movement Embraces Mysticism

To Emergents and All Others With the Same 'Intentions'

Brian McLaren Blames The Christian Faith for Colonialism…

Chris Rosebrough Speaks Out as He Fights For The Faith

Telltale Signs that “Latter Rain” has Poured into Your Church

WebSearch: TBN and the United Nations

Mandela, Maitreya and a Rainbow Nation

Amahoro – Transfiguration to Take Over Africa and Then the World

Jon Voight calls Obama a False Prophet

Does Rob Bell teach Kingdom Now Theology?

Ecumenical, Post Modern, Post Apartheid Dutch Reformed Church

What to EXPECT in the Last Days

Obama Promises Peace in Middle East – He Promises?

Curry Blake on What Not To Say and Do!

The Gospel of Christ Consciousness by Jacob Zuma & Ray McCauley

To those who insult and mock my Lord Jesus and King

TB Joshua – False Miracle Man

T.B. Joshua – The Deceiver

Who Are You? A God! Nooooooo Really?

Spirit Warriors a Christian CD?

Latter Rain – Taking Dominion with another Gospel another Christ

A New Breed – Are you one of them?

Kobus van Rensburg Immortal?

SGS: Kadafi at Zuma Inauguration

Will the Holy Spirit Make You Convulse?

SGS: Brother Branham is a Prophet

SGS: Jehovahs Witnesses in Vanderbijlpark

Sell a Defect Product to Keep Your Job as a Pastor

Another Student at TUKS Theology Loses the Plot

What does an Encounter mean or is that a G12?

People Who Run the World Meeting this Weekend?

Dream Interpretation #2 – Pot Plants

SGS: Positive Confessions About Marriage

Thoughts: Spend Less?

Google Searches: What is the sound before the anointing?

Glenn Grant – Occultist and The Second Son

Thoughts: Why is everything called a Movement?

Thoughts: Dream Interpretation #1 – Dogs

The Analogy of the Blue Sky

Dominionism and the Rise of Christian Imperialism

Anglican Church Appoints New Archbishop in an Emerging World

Pope calls for a two-state solution while…

Thoughts: Over the last few days on SABC3 …

Joyce Meyer is a Little God With a Big Christ Consciousness

The Meaning of Being Filled with the Holy Spirit

Why does Angus Buchan get promoted by God TV

Vibration of Sounds and Frequencies of Heaven – What Next?

Was there an actual Christian who prayed…

The Dominionist Faith of Angus Buchan – Faith Like Potatoes

William Branham – False Prophet

The Died-Again Christian Syndrome – By the University of Pretoria

Fire of The Holy Spirit – Judgment or Anointing?

How unique was the suffering of Jesus? Not unique at all!

Oprah Winfrey regarding Barack Obama…

Kobus van Rensburg – Self Anointed Prophet

Blasphemous Prophecy at Todd Bentley’s Ritual Ceremony